Back to Blog

A Guide to Responsible Phishing Simulations

Parker Byrd

A Phishing simulator, a popular tool for training employees to recognize malicious emails, can significantly influence an organization's culture and security posture—for better or worse. Employed wisely, they enhance security and trust; mishandled, they can breed skepticism and fear.

In this article, we’ll discuss:

- How can phishing simulations either bolster or harm organizational culture?

- Examples of responsible versus irresponsible simulation practices.

- Strategies for maximizing the positive impacts of phishing simulations.

As we dive deeper, we'll explore how to harness the power of phishing simulations to strengthen, rather than compromise, your company’s defenses and employee morale.

What are Phishing Simulations?

Phishing simulations are targeted exercises that mimic real-life phishing attacks to test employees' awareness and readiness to respond to malicious communications. By simulating phishing attempts in a controlled environment, organizations can identify vulnerable areas within their infrastructure and training gaps in their workforce. The primary goal is not just to test but to teach; effective simulations help employees recognize and appropriately react to phishing attempts, thereby reducing the risk of actual security breaches.

The Dual Impact of Phishing Simulations

Phishing simulations are a potent tool that can either strengthen or weaken an organization's culture and security posture. When designed and implemented thoughtfully, these simulations promote a culture of vigilance and empower employees with the knowledge they need to protect themselves and their organization. However, if handled carelessly, they can lead to mistrust, fear, and feeling tricked by one's own company.

Positive Impact 

Responsible simulations create learning opportunities that can boost employee confidence and improve organizational security. For instance, a well-executed simulation followed by constructive feedback helps employees learn from their mistakes in a safe environment. This approach reinforces best practices and celebrates improvement, significantly enhancing morale and security awareness.

Negative Impact

Conversely, simulations that "punish" or embarrass employees for falling for fake phishing emails can harm morale and trust. An example of poor practice is a simulation that tricks employees with deceptive cues or provides no educational feedback afterward. Such tactics can foster resentment and might lead to decreased vigilance against real threats, as employees might dismiss future emails as just another test.

Best Practices for Positive Outcomes

To ensure phishing simulations are effective and positively impact your organization, it's crucial to follow best practices that promote ethical use and educational value. Here are several guidelines to consider when planning and executing phishing simulations:

1. Transparency and Communication: 

Begin by informing employees about the purpose and benefits of phishing simulations. Clear communication ensures everyone understands that these exercises are meant to educate and protect the organization, not to trick or penalize them.

2. Realism without Deception: 

Design realistic yet fair simulations. Avoid overly deceptive tactics that could cause unnecessary panic or distress. Simulations should challenge employees and remain within the bounds of ethical training practices.

3. Immediate Feedback: 

Provide immediate and constructive feedback to participants after a simulation. This should include information on what phishing indicators were present and advice on how to respond in future scenarios. Positive reinforcement can help build confidence and competence.

4. Gradual Complexity: 

Start with simpler simulations, especially if your workforce is unfamiliar with phishing tactics. Gradually increase the complexity of your simulations to challenge better and teach your employees as they become more adept at recognizing phishing attempts.

5. Measure and Adapt: 

Continuously measure the effectiveness of your simulations and adapt them based on the outcomes. This could involve adjusting the frequency, complexity, or type of phishing emails. Always aim to keep the training relevant and engaging.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

While phishing simulations are a valuable tool for enhancing cybersecurity awareness, certain common mistakes can undermine their effectiveness and potentially harm employee morale. Here’s how to recognize and avoid these pitfalls:

1. Lack of Clear Objectives: 

Phishing simulations can confuse or mislead employees about their purpose without clear goals. Ensure each simulation has defined objectives, which are communicated to participants beforehand to align expectations and maximize learning outcomes.

2. Inappropriate Frequency: 

Conducting simulations too frequently can lead to fatigue and desensitization, while infrequent simulations may not sufficiently reinforce good habits. Find a balance that keeps employees alert but not overwhelmed.

3. Punitive Measures: 

Using simulations as a tool to punish or single out employees can create fear and distrust. Instead, focus on simulations as a learning tool, where mistakes are opportunities for growth rather than reasons for punishment.

4. Generic Scenarios: 

Simulations that don’t reflect the specific threats an organization may face are less effective. Tailor phishing scenarios to mimic the actual threats your employees are most likely to encounter, which increases the relevance and effectiveness of the training.

5. Neglecting Follow-up: 

Failing to provide feedback after simulations is a missed educational opportunity. Follow up with detailed insights about what was done well and what could be improved. This feedback loop is crucial for continuous improvement and maintaining engagement.

Scenarios of Responsible vs. Irresponsible Simulations

To illustrate the principles of responsible and irresponsible phishing simulations, here are some of the different ways a phishing simulations can go:

Responsible Simulation: A Tech Company’s Approach

A technology company noticed a rise in phishing attacks targeting their industry. They decided to conduct a phishing simulation that closely mirrored the tactics observed in actual attacks. Before the simulation, they communicated the purpose and expected outcomes to all employees, ensuring transparency. The simulation was complex enough to be challenging but designed not to trick employees unfairly. After the exercise, they provided comprehensive feedback and training sessions to discuss the simulation’s outcomes and teach correct responses. This approach led to a measurable improvement in their security posture and was positively received by the staff.

Irresponsible Simulation: A Financial Firm’s Misstep

A financial firm launched a phishing simulation without prior notice or explanation. The email used in the simulation mimicked the firm's HR department, offering employees a gift card as a bonus. 

Many employees were tricked, and there was significant confusion and panic. They also felt deflated and angry that the company would dangle a monetary reward as part of a trick.

The firm later revealed the exercise and reprimanded those who had clicked the link, leading to widespread distrust and a drop in morale. The simulation was seen as deceptive and punitive, highlighting how not to conduct such exercises.


Phishing simulations are a critical tool in the cybersecurity arsenal, capable of significantly enhancing or damaging an organization’s culture and security posture. When conducted responsibly, these simulations can bolster organizational culture, enhance security awareness, and equip employees with the skills needed to combat real-life threats. The best practices outlined, including maintaining transparency, offering constructive feedback, and avoiding punitive measures, are essential for maximizing the positive impacts of these simulations.

Today, you learned:

- The dual nature of phishing simulations and their impact on organizational culture.

- Examples of responsible and irresponsible simulation practices.

- Effective strategies to ensure phishing simulations strengthen your organization.

As a next step, talk to your team before you run phishing simulations to set the tone, gather feedback, and ensure the success of your program.

Sign up for our  newsletter

Get Free Exclusive Training Content in your inbox every month

Share on social media: 

More from the Blog

Never miss a post.

Enter your email below to be added to our blog newsletter and stay informed, educated, and entertained!
We will never share your email address with third parties.